n. 20 The mask that is more honest than you

Teilen

Servus together,

here I am, Daniel, thought-chirping my way into your head again.

-> you can find the english translation here: https://playfulpassage.substack.com/

A hundred pizzas and a table full of games

But first: thank you for this weekend.

We had our pizza festival, and next to the oven stood a table with our test games and our favorite games. People ate pizza, people played, some did both at the same time.

I have to say honestly: exactly that was one of the main dreams behind Playtipus from the very beginning. Not the fair, not the shop, not the numbers. But a table, good food, games, and people who stay seated longer than they actually planned. That this now simply happened, on a normal weekend, makes me very grateful.

Have you ever felt exhaustion while making content, without being able to say why?

Recently, and that has been a little while now, I told you about my borderlining relationship with social media. In one moment I love it very much, in the next it goes completely against the grain for me.

A particularly telling moment came on an evening with three close people from family and circle of friends. There was a rich bolognese, red wine and the game We're Not Really Strangers. Before the game you write down what the others' first impression of you was, and then you move through three question-card rounds into ever deeper topics.

One question I got was: Which topic would you have to solve or forget to have maximally more free time?

Quick as a flash my brother fired back: "Dani, your social media dilemma. If you didn't keep rehashing that all the time, you'd easily have two more days a week."

Busted.

The third way

I neither want to become an addicted user of these platforms, nor an analog anarchist who rejects everything digital. I want to build my own systems that help me become freer in doing what I love.

And I really do have the feeling: when I do that consistently, exactly that leads to others being able to love my work. Fully in line with Rick Rubin's principle that the audience comes last.

Playful Practice 🦦: Get foreign eyes on yourself.

I can really only warmly recommend gathering other people's perspectives on you. Not because you wouldn't already know what they say yourself. But because you get into feeling in a completely different way. Especially with the heavy questions, the topics that hold your attention captive.

Three ways you can try this week: Ask someone directly. Best someone who has known you for a long time and has little fear of you. Don't ask for praise, ask for observation. Keep an attention journal. A single goal: write down where your attention really goes day by day. What draws the resources onto itself? Collect this over a few days without judging it right away. Take a foreign perspective. What would person XY say about it? Or the classic question from counseling: If a good friend were in exactly my situation, what would I tell her? Often something very kind comes out that we cannot reach in ourselves, because an inner driver stands in the way.

Externalized self-disclosure

This way of talking about ourselves by using symbols is called externalization.

You can see it beautifully in role-playing games like Dungeons and Dragons. The character sheet is not a rule sheet, it is a safety distance with values on it. You play a character, it is not really about you, and exactly through that a deeper honesty arises. Perhaps you are living self-disclosure there without being aware of it at first.

In children the effect is well studied. In a randomized study with 139 children, four perspectives were compared, including the question of how a competent media character would feel in this situation, the classic Batman, that is. Children with less developed self-control benefited the most from taking the detour via the character. So the detour does not help everyone equally, but most strongly those who otherwise find it hardest.

For adults there is a small, fine qualitative work with eight autistic adults who played D&D online for six weeks. Its core finding: interacting as yourself is exhausting, interacting in the character relieves. The character acts as a buffer.

And because it is fair to say this right away: those are children in a lab task and eight adults without a control group. I present this here as a mechanism and as an attitude, not as proof of effect. The study on our own game is still pending.

How this works in Insightopia

Exactly this externalized self-disclosure is built into Insightopia.

Whenever a person is talking about a topic and answering a question, everyone else holds picture cards in their hands. Whoever wants gives back a card that created a resonance in them just now, and maybe says a sentence about it. Or not.

The person who spoke receives feedback in this way, where they may check for themselves what of it belongs to them and what does not. For me that means: we expand our knowledge about ourselves by opening a resonance space in a playful way.

The counter-test: when the mask sticks

There is also the counterpoint, and it is important.

Through distancing we can also end up in splitting off. In the role-playing context one speaks of bleed, the spillover between person and character. Bleed cuts in both directions: the character can change how you feel outside the game, but it can also become the mask that sticks, and then the self-reference does not come back in the end.

These masks we put on in the game context can be windows, then. But they can also remain hiding places. Distance is a passage, not a permanent state. The goal is the return to the I, not the escape from it.

Derek Sivers writes about this: "Manners are shallow. Honesty is deep." Politeness is shallow, honesty is deep.

And still, or precisely because of that, I believe: sometimes a truth only comes out via a detour. I step into a role, and suddenly I am allowed to express myself without having to be incredibly correct. After all, I am only playing. Often exactly that creates a depth, because we are not caught in the nested regulations of our everyday life.

The detour via the character is perhaps not cowardice, but the friendliest way to be honest.

From the workshop

Where we currently stand in the game process:

  • Illustration. We are in the process of illustrating the last cards.
  • Test rounds. We had some very lovely test play rounds with wonderful people. It is running smoothly.
  • Printing. We are soon going into a small print run with a Belgian company.

If you want to be part of it

Because the print run will be small, this is the most honest moment to tell you: You can pre-order Insightopia now.

In the coming weeks the first small print run goes into production. Whoever pre-orders is part of this first round, and quite incidentally you help decide with it how many games we can have printed at all.

👉 Pre-order Insightopia

And if you do not want or cannot order right now: tell someone about it who you think should be sitting at such a table. That helps us almost as much.

I look forward very much to the exchange and to developing many even deeper games together with you.

With love and play,

Daniel & the Playtipus crew

Sources and findings

  • Grenell, A., Prager, E. O., Schaefer, C., Kross, E., Duckworth, A. L., & Carlson, S. M. (2018). Individual differences in the effectiveness of self-distancing for young children's emotion regulation. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, volume 37, issue 1, pages 84 to 100. doi.org/10.1111/bjdp.12259
  • Atherton, G., Hathaway, R., Visuri, I., & Cross, L. (2024). A critical hit: Dungeons and Dragons as a buff for autistic people. Autism, volume 29, issue 2, pages 382 to 394. doi.org/10.1177/13623613241275260
  • Lis, E., Chiniara, C., Biskin, R., & Montoro, R. (2015). Psychiatrists' Perceptions of Role-Playing Games.Psychiatric Quarterly, volume 86, issue 3, pages 381 to 384. doi.org/10.1007/s11126-015-9339-5
  • Derek Sivers, How to Live, chapter "Love". sive.rs/htl22
  • Rick Rubin, The Creative Act, on the principle that the audience comes last.
  • On the term bleed: Sarah Lynne Bowman, Bleed: The Spillover Between Player and Character, nordiclarp.org (2015).
  • We're Not Really Strangers, card game by Koreen Odiney.